Qatar - 51.77

97

The black sheep of the Arab world

The world cup has been a surprisingly important moment for Qatar’s trajectory as a country. As part of Qatar’s attempts to diversify its once one-note petrostate economy, Qatar bribed FIFA to host the 2022 World Cup. Doha previously lacked the facilities to host the most popular sporting event in the world and thus Qatar had to invest heavily into building stadiums and hotels to host the World Cup. In the process of building these facilities, Qatar came under close scrutiny for its use of slave labor to build the stadiums. Qatar’s Kafala System, used across the Middle East, at the time amounted to little more than temporary slavery. After drawing ire from the international community, Qatar was forced to reform this system and it is now one of the least inhumane in the Middle East. Qatar has long been unique among the Gulf States, though. Qatar is significantly freer than any of the other Gulf States and has long allowed for significantly more free expression than its neighbors. Qatar’s freedom of the press is significantly more intact than in any of the other Gulf States and Qatar also allows for generally uncensored education. Additionally, Qatar is one of only two Gulf States (the other being Kuwait) to democratically elect some of its parliament. All of this praise must be placed in the context of the Gulf, however. The Persian Gulf is one of the most authoritarian, culturally repressive regions on Earth, and while Qatar is the lesser evil of the region the evil is most certainly still there. While unenforced, homosexuality remains punishable by death. Non-Muslims are under constant scrutiny and apostasy is punishable by death (though this law goes unenforced). Qatar is entirely hostile to women and LGBT. Additionally, while Qatar has made significant improvements to its Kafala system, migrants remain mistreated and are subject to few worker protections. Qatar has a long way to go and it is unclear what, if anything, will push Qatar to progress and more than it absolutely has to.

Human Rights - 33

Qatar retains the death penalty and the last execution was carried out in 2020. Qatari law allows for corporal punishment, specifically flogging, for certain offenses (namely extramarital sex) though this law goes unenforced. Women are discriminated against in Qatari court. Men can escape rape charges by marrying their victim (women have few rights to avoid marriage, both in Qatari culture and under Qatari law). Additionally, a woman’s testimony only counts as half of a man’s in court. Women are discriminated against under Qatari law in the fields of inheritance, custody, marriage, and divorce. Qatar allegedly possesses an extensive surveillance network and is known to closely monitor social media. The Qatari government has been accused of possessing the ability to intercept and monitor phone calls, text messages, and emails. Qatar is under the kafala system, a system of hiring migrant labor used across the Arab World. Qatar’s application of the kafala system, especially in recent years, has been regarded as one of the least inhumane. Qatari migrant workers can join unions, change jobs or quit without permission, leave the country, and are subject to a minimum wage. However, a number of Qatari labor laws do not apply to kafala migrants, meaning that they can be worked longer hours with fewer breaks and fewer safety regulations. Additionally, migrant workers often complain of blatant discrimination. Professionals are often relegated to menial labor jobs and workers of certain nationalities are paid less. Qatar’s media sector is significantly more open than most other Gulf Coast states. The privately-owned al-Jazeera receives some state funding but is generally allowed to operate freely. Abroad, al-Jazeera is generally regarded as a largely unbiased news source. Other Qatari media outlets face some restrictions, but foreign media outlets are generally free to operate and Qatar is viewed as a safe country for journalists. A January 2020 penal code amendment prescribes up to five years of jail time for publishing “false news,” but this law has gone generally unenforced. Apostasy is punishable by death but this law has never gone enforced. Despite no recorded executions in history for apostasy, Muslims converting is still strongly discouraged. Prosletyzation by non-Muslims is illegal. During COVID, the government mandated the use of the Ehteraz contract-tracing app. The app tracked the location of its users and reported this information to the government, raising security and privacy concerns. Protest organizers must obtain an assembly permit from the Interior Ministry, which is rarely issued. Homosexuality is punishable by death, though this law goes unenforced. Abortion is legal to preserve the physical health of the woman as well as in cases of rape and fetal impairment. Qatar received a five-point penalty for retaining an unenforced death penalty for homosexuality.

Democracy - 20

Qatar is an absolute emirate. The hereditary emir exerts absolute control over the country’s executive branch. Thirty of the country’s forty-five Advisory Council seats are directly elected while fifteen are appointed by the emir. The Advisory Council has the power to draft legislation and provide advice to the emir but the emir holds the final say on all legislation. Elections are generally free and fair. Political parties are banned in Qatar but opposition candidates were elected. Dissident factions within the Qatari royal family often advocate for change but there are no real rotations of executive power outside of the royal family.

Freedom - 26

Qatar has one of the most open media environments of any Gulf Coast state. The privately-owned al-Jazeera receives some state funding but its reporting is generally regarded as relatively unbiased. Other media outlets in Qatar face some restrictions but foreign media outlets are generally free to operate and Qatar is regarded as a safe country for journalists. The independent English-language newspaper Doha News was restored in 2020 after being shut down following a rejected permit renewal application in 2016. A January 2020 amendment to the penal code prescribed sentences of up to five years for the publishing of “false news.” This law has gone generally unenforced. Apostasy is punishable by death, though this law has never been enforced. Despite a lack of executions for apostasy, Muslims are still strongly discouraged from converting. Prosletyzation by non-Muslims is illegal. Qatar has a significantly more vibrant sector of both public and private discussion than other Gulf Coast states, but protest organizers must still follow the stringent process of obtaining a permit from the Interior Ministry. During the COVID pandemic, the government mandated the use of the Ehteraz contact-tracing app. This app tracked user’s locations and reported them to the government, raising concerns about security and privacy. Qatar allegedly maintains an extensive surveillance network and is known to closely monitor social media. The government allegedly has the ability to intercept and monitor phone calls, text messages, and emails. Islam is the official religion of Qatar and Muslim organizations are subject to regulation by the government. Non-Muslims are not permitted to worship in public. Qatar is largely receptive to foreign education but local Qatari schools are subject to some censorship. Drug trafficking is punishable by death. Semi-automatic rifles and handguns are legal under a stringent permit process. Qatar received a five-point penalty for prescribing the death penalty for drug trafficking.

Economy - 88

Health - 92

Qatar has a life expectancy of 80 years and an infant mortality rate of 0.57%. 35.1% of Qataris are obese and around 1% are malnourished. Qatar’s healthcare system provides world-class care for free to all citizens, while employers are expected to provide for kafala workers on their payroll. 96.2% of Qataris have access to clean, running water.

Corruption - 93

The government exerts near absolute top-down control over petroleum production in the country, but Qatar Petroleum is generally not regarded as corrupt. Qatar bribed FIFA to host the 2022 World Cup. Doha lacked the capacity to host the cup at the time that they won the bid.

Competency - 95

The government is failing to protect migrant workers.

Future - 33

The Qatari economy is heavily reliant on oil and must diversify soon if Qatar is to retain its status as one of the wealthiest countries on Earth. Due to controversy surrounding the World Cup, it is unclear whether or not the World Cup will truly increase tourism in the country. Qatar’s economy has been shrinking as a result of the Arab Cold War. It is also unclear when this cold conflict will end.

Actions Abroad - 64

Qatar supported attempts at democratic uprisings in Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt, and Bahrain during the Arab Spring. The Qatar Development Fund finances development projects and humanitarian aid in Africa. Qatar supports the government of Somalia. Qatar, along with Turkiye, are the primary opponents of recognizing Somalia. Many Arab League states have severed relations with Qatar, as Qatar maintains relatively close relations with Iran.

No Qataris live below the international poverty line and the country does not have a national poverty line. 3.45% of Qataris are unemployed. Qatar has an extremely high economic disparity. Qatar has a minimum wage of $275 per month, which kafala workers are subject to. Qatar has a very strong universal healthcare system, providing all Qatari citizens with world-class healthcare. Employers are expected to provide for kafala workers on their payroll. The Qatari economy shrunk 3.7% in 2020 and grew 0.8% in 2019. The Qatari economy has been seeing contractions since the start of the Arab Cold War in 2017.